2002 Uberlingen mid-air collision - What Happened When Two Airplanes Collided At An Altitude Of 35,000 Feet
Two Planes Collide In Mid-Air (Accident)
Date 1 July 2002, night time 8:10 minutes, a total of 60 passengers, including 45 schoolchildren, were waiting for the flight at Moscow's Domodedovo International Airport. These 45 Russian schoolchildren were from to the city of Ufa and were on a school trip organized by the local UNESCO committee to the Costa Dorada area of Spain. 38 minutes later at about 8:48 minutes, Flight 2937 (a Tupolev Tu-154 passenger jet) of Bashkirian Airlines with 60 passengers and nine crew members took off from Moscow, Russia, to Barcelona, Spain. The plane was ready to cover a distance of 3000 kilometers in 4 hours and 20 minutes. Around 11 pm the airplane entered the airspace in Switzerland. This airspace was being controlled by Skyguide, a private Swiss airspace control company. At 11 pm, Peter Nielsen was there in the control room with one of his companions as an air traffic controller. 1 July was a very busy day in terms of air traffic from morning to evening but after 11 pm at night, there was no landing schedule for any plane at any airport that existed in that entire airspace and the air traffic passing through that airspace was also reduced to a great extent. Therefore, Peter Nielsen's colleague gave responsibility for his workstation to Peter and went for a break. This was against the rules of Skyguide, but was a common practice over the years and was known and tolerated by management. That means, Peter was now handling the responsibility of two workstations simultaneously, where airspace traffic was being shown on the first radar system, and the planes landing at the airport on the second radar system were being monitored.
On the other hand, at 11:06 pm, a DHL Flight 611 (a Boeing 757 cargo jet) departed from Bergamo, Italy, to Brussels, Belgium. At around 11:10, Peter Nielsen was informed that his main radar image processing system has been shut down for maintenance, so now he will have to use the fallback system. At 11:21 pm DHL Flight 611 entered Peter Nielsen's air space and the plane's pilot approached peter and asked for permission to fly at 36000 feet of altitude. Before giving permission, peter regulated the air traffic and started doing a normal calculation that there is no other plane on this altitude and the same route. But then a message from a delayed Aero Lloyd flight 1135 came on the second radar system that they have to land at a nearby airport, so peter had to switch from his ongoing task and moved to the second radar system. Peter tried to contact the nearby airport tower but his phone was unable to work due to the maintenance program at the workstation. Therefore, he returned to the first radar system because right now flight 1135 had ten minutes to land. After coming to the first radar system, peter approved DHL Flight 611's request for flying at an altitude of 36000 feet and then again tried to make contact with the nearby airport tower for the landing of flight 1135.
The front section of the plane directly hit the ground vertically, while the rear section spins in the air and fell on the ground after a few seconds. The collision was so terrible that all the 60 passengers (including 45 children) and 9 crew members of Flight 2937 were killed. On the other side, DHL Flight 611 was also severely damaged due to the collision. The vertical stabilizer of DHL Flight 611 was 80% broken, due to which the plane was uncontrolled in the air. After struggling for some time, DHL Flight crashed into a wooded area close to the village of Taisersdorf, 7 kilometers away from the accident location, causing the plane's tail section to ripped from the fuselage by trees just before impact. A total of 71 people died in this horrible accident, 69 people on Flight 2937, and the 2 on DHL Flight 611.
It could be said that if both airplane pilots followed those TCAS automated instructions rather than Air Traffic Controller Peter Nielsen's instructions, the collision would not have occurred. Aero Lloyd's Flight 1135 can also be considered another reason for this mid-air collision, forcing Peter Nielsen to switch continuously from Flight 1135 to Flight 2937 and DHL Flight 611. But the biggest reason was that the other controller was on break during his duty and the maintenance work that was being carried out on the main radar image processing system forced peter to use a fallback system.
















